Site icon DPSS Ltd

Force Majeure Contract Dispute: What Contract Managers Must Know

A Supreme Court dispute over sanctions, payment terms and force majeure shows why contract managers must understand contractual rights.

A major Supreme Court ruling illustrates why contract managers must understand the precise legal meaning of contractual obligations. In RTI Ltd v MUR Shipping BV, the shipping company agreed to transport goods under a contract requiring payment in US dollars.

Following the imposition of US sanctions affecting the customer’s parent company, difficulties arose concerning payment in the agreed currency. The shipping company invoked a force majeure clause and suspended performance. The customer offered to pay in euros instead, with arrangements to convert the money into dollars and compensate the shipping company for any resulting loss.

The customer argued that refusing this alternative was unreasonable and brought proceedings for breach of contract. The Court concluded that, in the absence of express contractual wording to the contrary, a reasonable endeavours obligation did not require the company to accept performance different from that specified in the contract.

In my experience, commercial managers regularly face situations where contractual performance becomes difficult. These include supply chain disruption, international sanctions, material shortages, unexpected cost increases and changes in regulations. In these circumstances, managers may assume that commercial reasonableness requires the parties to accept alternative arrangements.

However, commercial reasonableness and legal obligations are not always the same.

A contract manager needs to understand whether an alternative is legally required, commercially desirable or something that must be formally negotiated and agreed.

The importance of contract law knowledge

This case highlights several fundamental principles.

First, contractual rights are determined by the agreement and the applicable law, not simply by what one party considers fair.

Second, force majeure does not automatically excuse performance whenever circumstances become difficult.

Third, reasonable endeavours obligations have legal boundaries.

My Practical Contract Law and Drafting course will enable participants to fully understand force majeure, contractual interpretation and variations and will help managers make commercially sound decisions without inadvertently surrendering valuable contractual rights. This course is also available as an in-house tailored event.

Check out the course here

Exit mobile version