Site icon DPSS Ltd

Breach of Contract Damages: Who Can Claim Compensation?

A September 2026 Supreme Court ruling highlights the risks of assuming that a company can recover contractual losses suffered by its subsidiary.

A Supreme Court judgment delivered on 17 September 2026 raises an important issue for organisations operating through subsidiaries and other associated companies. In Forthwell Ltd v Pontegadea UK Ltd, the dispute concerned the historic Rogano restaurant premises in Glasgow.

Forthwell was the tenant under a lease, while its subsidiary operated the restaurant. Following flooding and other damage, the premises could not reopen.

Forthwell pursued claims against its landlord relating to alleged breaches of repairing obligations. The trading losses had been suffered by the subsidiary, which was not itself a party to the lease.

Forthwell sought to recover losses suffered by the subsidiary, including claimed past lost profits of approximately £179,000 and anticipated future lost profits of approximately £934,000.

The landlord challenged Forthwell’s entitlement to recover those losses. The dispute raised a fundamental question: when can one contracting party recover damages for losses suffered by another company?

The judgment examined the circumstances in which losses suffered by third parties can be recovered under Scots contract law.

In my experience, many organisations operate through complicated contractual structures.

A parent company may sign a contract while a subsidiary receives the services, or one company may procure equipment used by several businesses within a corporate group.

If something goes wrong, the company suffering the financial loss may not be the company holding the contractual rights.

Contract managers should understand the importance of identifying the contracting parties and determining which organisations are entitled to enforce contractual obligations.

My Practical Contract Law and Drafting course 22-23 February 2027 provides a basic understanding of contract law that can help managers recognise potentially serious weaknesses in contractual arrangements before they develop into costly disputes. This course is also available as an in-house tailored event.

Check out the course here

Exit mobile version