16 Nov 2026

Contract Termination Disputes: Lessons from a 2026 Supreme Court Ruling

A 2026 Supreme Court ruling highlights the dangers of incorrectly terminating contracts.

A Supreme Court judgment delivered on 15 January 2026 provides an important warning for contract managers: believing that a supplier or customer has breached a contract does not necessarily mean you have the legal right to terminate it.

The dispute, Providence Building Services Ltd v Hexagon Housing Association Ltd, concerned a construction contract incorporating the widely used JCT Design and Build conditions. Hexagon made two late payments to its contractor, Providence Building Services. Following the second late payment, Providence attempted to terminate the contract, believing that the contractual termination provisions entitled it to do so.

However, the Court examined the precise wording of the termination provisions. It concluded that the contractor could not terminate merely because the employer had made two late payments. Under the relevant contractual mechanism, a right to terminate needed to have arisen following the first default before the repeated-default termination provision could operate. Therefore, Providence was not entitled to terminate under the provision relied upon.

In my experience, many contract managers assume that repeated poor performance automatically creates a right to terminate. The organisation could find itself facing a claim for wrongful termination. The commercial consequences may include damages, additional procurement costs, project delays and expensive litigation.

Contract managers need to understand the difference between a breach of contract and a contractual right to terminate.

Contract managers do not need to be qualified lawyers. However, they must understand the legal implications of the decisions they make when managing contractual performance. My Practical Contract Law and Drafting course – 22- 23 February 2027- enables commercial professionals to understand contractual rights, avoid costly mistakes and identify when specialist legal advice is necessary. This course is also available as an in-house tailored event.

Check out our course here