17 Nov 2026

A delayed delivery led to a £1.85 million damages award

A Supreme Court judgment from July 2026 demonstrates how the interpretation of a contractual compensation clause can have substantial financial consequences.

In Great Asia Maritime Ltd v Orion Shipping and Trading LLC, the dispute concerned the sale of a vessel for US$15 million. The sellers failed to have the vessel ready for delivery by the agreed date because of their proven negligence. The buyers exercised their contractual right to cancel the agreement.

However, the dispute did not end there; the buyers claimed US$1.85 million in damages, representing the difference between the agreed purchase price and the higher market value of the vessel.

The sellers argued that the buyers could not recover these damages because the breach did not amount to a repudiatory breach. The buyers relied on the contractual compensation provisions. The Supreme Court unanimously dismissed the sellers’ appeal, confirming that the relevant contractual wording entitled the buyers to recover loss-of-bargain damages in these circumstances.

In my experience, contract managers frequently deal with compensation clauses, service credits, liquidated damages, liability limitations and contractual remedies. However, they often do not fully appreciate how these provisions interact with the general law of damages.

My Practical Contract Law and Drafting course, 22- 23 February 2027, provides a practical understanding of contract law that can help managers identify potential liabilities, manage disputes more effectively and avoid making expensive assumptions about contractual remedies. This course is also available as an in-house tailored event.

Check out our course here